An anonymous post today described a multi-year Google scheme to shut down AdSense accounts without explanation and take publishers’ money. Attempting to quash the allegations before they spread further, Google described them as “complete fiction.”

A Pastebin post by someone claiming to be a former Google employee who witnessed such abuses is making the rounds among webmasters and on Hacker News.

The post describes an elaborate scheme starting in 2009 to flag, audit and ban sites that were earning $1,000, $5,000 and $10,000 per month from shared revenue generated by Google AdSense ads — the simple contextual ads that publishers can run on their sites with minimal work.

Without providing documentation or naming names, the poster said he or she was on the AdSense team and heard one executive describe an updated policy as “shelter the possible problem makers, and fuck the rest.”

While stories of Google turning its back on the “don’t be evil” stance of its early days have increasing currency, the logic of this one seems a little strange. Shutting down publisher accounts because they start earning money would deprive Google of any future revenue, too.

Google said in an email reply to an inquiry about the post: “This description of our AdSense policy enforcement process is a complete fiction. The color-coding and ‘extreme quality control’ programs the author describes don’t exist. Our teams and automated systems work around the clock to stop bad actors and protect our publishers, advertisers and users.”

The company said it does flag and disable publisher accounts for various reasons, including inappropriate content, misleading ad presentation and “clickbombing.” Google said it refunds money to advertisers when abuse is found.




4 comments
nzouber
nzouber

Same thing happened to me, I was clean as snow, 100% by the book.... One day, out of the blue, the email came... Account disabled, reason field.. Left blank !! My name and anything associated to me are banned from adsense for life.... For what reason ?! Only God knows... I never got any warning and was doing everything by according to their policy. All I know is that they are certainly not acting like a company who has for moto "don't be evil"... Quite the contrary... My gut tells me something is fishy... Those guys are not to be trusted... They are like a mafia... exactly the same, they knock you down to the ground, take your life down, and spit on you, without ever telling you why !! Never rely on Adsense as your main revenue source, never !!!

Peter M
Peter M

They've been doing it for years... they also have screwed a number of YouTube partners by claiming "clickbombing" . shutting down their accounts and not providing any proof or data... they're a bad actor on many levels. 

JamesD
JamesD

Of course they deny it... that doesn't mean it isn't true.

FF22
FF22

"Shutting down publisher accounts because they start earning money would deprive Google of any future revenue, too. "

Not really. Google could still display the same ads on other sites, and generate virtually the same amount of money.


That said AdSense indeed has a serious problem, because Google does a really lousy job at (not) filtering out scraper and aggregation sites, thus inducing a race to the bottom in regards of content generation and distribution.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 288,394 other followers